Your inner critic is an asshole.
It tells you you're not good enough. You're doing it wrong. You're stupid. Lazy. Selfish. Broken. Too much. Not enough. Fundamentally flawed.
And you've spent years trying to kill it.
Positive affirmations to drown it out. Self-compassion practices to counter it. Therapy sessions to understand where it came from and make it stop. Spiritual bypassing to transcend it.
None of it works. Because you can't kill the inner critic. You can only drive it deeper into shadow where it becomes more powerful and harder to see.
Here's what actually works: befriending it.
Not accepting its judgments as truth. Not letting it run your life. But recognizing it as a part of yourself that developed for a reason, has a purpose (even if outdated), and contains information you need.
The inner critic is shadow material. It's the internalized voice of everyone who judged you, criticized you, rejected you. It's the part of you that learned to judge yourself before others could, to protect yourself from rejection by rejecting yourself first.
And like all shadow material, you can't eliminate it. You can only integrate it.
This is shadow work nobody wants to do because it requires treating the voice that tortures you with curiosity and compassion instead of trying to make it shut up.
But when you do this—when you actually befriend your inner critic instead of fighting it—something transforms that years of battling it never accomplished.
Where the Inner Critic Comes From
Your inner critic isn't random. It didn't just appear to torture you. It developed for specific survival reasons.
The inner critic is internalized criticism
As a child, you received messages about what was acceptable and what wasn't. From parents, teachers, siblings, peers, culture.
"You're too loud." "Why can't you be more like your sister?" "That's stupid." "You're being dramatic." "You're lazy." "Nobody will love you if you're like that."
You internalized these voices. Took them inside. Made them your own. Because internalizing the criticism and judging yourself first was safer than being blindsided by others' judgment.
The logic of the inner critic:
"If I judge myself before others judge me, I can protect myself from their rejection."
"If I point out my flaws first, others can't use them against me."
"If I'm harsh enough with myself, I'll fix my unacceptable parts and become acceptable."
This is survival strategy. The inner critic developed to keep you safe by keeping you in line, making you acceptable, preventing rejection.
It's not evil. It's protective. Just using a brutal, outdated strategy.
The problem: What protected you as a powerless child now limits you as a powerful adult. But the critic doesn't know you've grown. It's still operating from the original threat: "If you're unacceptable, you'll be rejected. Rejection means death."
The Inner Critic as Shadow Material
Most people don't think of the inner critic as shadow because it's so conscious—you hear it all the time.
But the inner critic is absolutely shadow material:
1. It's the disowned judge
You probably pride yourself on not being judgmental. You try to be accepting, compassionate, open.
Meanwhile, your inner critic is viciously judgmental—of you. It's all the judgment you refuse to direct at others turned inward.
The critic is your disowned judgmental part.
2. It's the internalized rejector
You don't want to reject others. You want to accept people, include them, see them.
Meanwhile, your inner critic is constantly rejecting you. It's the part that says "you're not acceptable as you are."
The critic is your disowned rejecting part.
3. It operates unconsciously (even when conscious)
Yes, you hear the critic. But you're usually not conscious of:
- When it's activated (what triggers it)
- What purpose it's serving
- What it's protecting you from
- What alternative responses are available
- That you have choice about whether to believe it
It operates automatically, which is shadow functioning.
4. It's split off from your conscious self-image
If you asked "Are you self-critical?" you'd say yes. But you probably don't identify as "a harsh critic." You think of yourself as kind, accepting, compassionate.
The critic is the harsh judge you've split off from your identity.
Why Fighting the Critic Doesn't Work
You've tried everything to make the inner critic shut up. Positive affirmations. Self-compassion mantras. Cognitive restructuring. Telling it to fuck off.
None of it works long-term because:
Fighting creates more shadow
When you fight the critic, you're trying to eliminate a part of yourself. That part just goes deeper underground where it becomes more powerful.
What you resist persists: The critic gets stronger when you resist it. Your attention on fighting it energizes it.
You can't out-argue it: The critic has unlimited ammunition. For every positive thought, it has three criticisms. You cannot win a debate with your inner critic.
Suppression doesn't equal integration: Drowning out the critic with affirmations doesn't integrate it. It just covers it temporarily.
The critic has valid information: When you fight it, you miss the legitimate information it's trying to give you (even if it's delivering that information brutally).
It's using your energy: The inner critic is part of you. Fighting it is fighting yourself, which exhausts you.
The Befriending Approach
Instead of fighting the critic, you befriend it. This doesn't mean accepting its judgments as true. It means treating it as a part of yourself that needs integration, not elimination.
Step 1: Personify It
Give your inner critic a form, a character, a presence.
Close your eyes. Imagine your inner critic has a physical form. What does it look like?
Sometimes it looks like a specific person (a parent, teacher, someone who criticized you).
Sometimes it looks like a harsh figure (judge, executioner, critic, monster).
Sometimes it's a voice without form, but you can give it one.
Why this works: Personifying creates distance. The critic isn't you. It's a part of you. Now you can dialogue with it rather than being overtaken by it.
Step 2: Name It
Give your inner critic a name.
Not a mean name. A name that acknowledges it without making it the enemy.
Some people use: "The Judge," "The Protector," "The Harsh One," "The Critic."
Or use an actual name if it resembles someone specific.
Why this works: Naming creates more distance and makes it easier to recognize when it's active. "Oh, that's the Judge talking" rather than "I'm a terrible person."
Step 3: Thank It
This is the part nobody wants to do. Thank the inner critic for trying to protect you.
What you say:
"Thank you for trying to keep me safe by pointing out my flaws before others could."
"Thank you for trying to make me acceptable so I wouldn't be rejected."
"Thank you for trying to protect me from the pain of criticism."
"I know you developed to help me survive. Thank you."
Why this works: The critic developed with positive intent (protection). Acknowledging that changes your relationship with it from adversarial to collaborative.
Step 4: Ask What It Needs
Instead of telling the critic to shut up, ask it: "What do you need right now?"
Let it answer. Don't control the response. Let it come from the unconscious.
Often the critic responds:
"I need you to take this seriously."
"I need you to prepare for rejection."
"I need you to fix this so you'll be acceptable."
"I need you to see the danger you're not seeing."
Why this works: Understanding what the critic needs reveals its actual purpose, which is never just "torture you for fun."
Step 5: Ask What It's Protecting You From
"What are you protecting me from?"
This is the key question. The critic isn't just attacking. It's defending against something.
Common answers:
"I'm protecting you from rejection."
"I'm protecting you from being hurt by others' criticism."
"I'm protecting you from failure."
"I'm protecting you from being too much and overwhelming people."
"I'm protecting you from being not enough and being abandoned."
Why this works: When you understand what the critic is protecting you from, you can address the actual fear rather than just battling the critic.
Step 6: Update It
Tell your inner critic: "Thank you for protecting me. That threat was real when I was young. But I'm an adult now. I have different resources. I can handle rejection without dying."
Give it evidence:
"I've been rejected before and survived."
"I have people who accept me even when I'm imperfect."
"I have skills now to handle criticism."
"Being unacceptable to some people doesn't mean I'm unacceptable to everyone."
Why this works: The critic is operating on outdated information. Updating it helps it recognize the original threat isn't as powerful now.
Step 7: Negotiate New Terms
"I know you want to protect me. But your current method is hurting me. Can we find a different way for you to help?"
Negotiate what the critic's new role could be:
"Instead of tearing me down, could you just alert me when something needs attention?"
"Instead of saying I'm a failure, could you just say 'this isn't working, let's adjust'?"
"Instead of attacking me, could you be a constructive coach?"
Why this works: You're not eliminating the critic. You're integrating it into a healthier role that still serves its protective function without being destructive.
What Changes When You Befriend the Critic
After months of befriending practice, here's what shifts:
- The critic gets quieter: Not gone. But less frequent, less intense, less controlling.
- The critic becomes more helpful: Instead of "You're stupid," it says "That didn't work, try differently."
- You respond faster: You catch the critic activating and can interrupt the pattern before spiraling.
- You trust yourself more: When you're not constantly fighting an internal enemy, you have more energy for living.
- Your relationship with mistakes changes: Mistakes become information rather than proof of worthlessness.
- You become more compassionate with others: When you stop attacking yourself, you naturally become less judgmental of others.
- You have more emotional range: Energy that was spent fighting the critic becomes available for other emotions.
This is integration: The critic doesn't disappear. It becomes a part of you that you work with consciously rather than a shadow part controlling you unconsciously.
The Befriending Paradox
Here's the paradox: When you stop trying to eliminate the inner critic, it loses its power.
Fighting it makes it stronger. Befriending it makes it softer.
Trying to kill it drives it into shadow. Integrating it brings it into consciousness where you have choice.
Hating it gives it energy. Compassion for it dissolves its harsh edge.
This is shadow work: Not eliminating the difficult parts. Integrating them. Bringing them into consciousness. Working with them rather than being controlled by them.
Your inner critic is an asshole. But it's your asshole. Part of you. Developed to protect you. Still trying to keep you safe using brutal, outdated methods.
You can't kill it. But you can befriend it. And that changes everything.
Time to stop fighting. Time to start befriending. Your inner critic is waiting. It might be surprised when you approach with curiosity instead of combat. But it will respond. They always do.
This article is part of our Archetypes collection. Read our comprehensive Shadow Work and Archetypes to explore shadow work, Carl Jung's psychology, and practical transformation through consciousness integration.
.jpg)